Thu, Mar 28, 2024
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS pod
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Industry Updates

'Noisy' errors by wealth managers/financial advisers can be caused by irrelevant factors, says study

Tuesday, May 25, 2021
Opalesque Industry Update - A study with financial advisers to make recommendations for imaginary clients found that risk tolerance assessments resulted in wildly different interpretations, which had a massive impact on client recommendations.

In one instance, an adviser recommended a 'very low' level' of risk for an imaginary client while another recommended a 'very high level'. For another, advisers were evenly split between recommending low, medium, or high levels of risk. The study, which was conducted by behavioural finance experts Oxford Risk, found advisers gave 'remarkably different judgements' on how much investment risk was suitable for clients with the same hypothetical information, and asset allocations were "scattershot". Even in cases where advisers agreed on the suitable risk levels, they disagreed on what kind of portfolio to recommend to clients.

Analysis of the results of the study, conducted in partnership with South African firm Momentum Investments and South Africa's professional body The Financial Planning Institute, found recommendations 'were closer to totally random than totally consistent'. 

The report Under the Microscope: 'Noise' and investment advice highlights the influence of 'noise' in the advice process driving variations which cannot be explained. 'Noisy' errors can be caused by irrelevant factors such as advisers' current mood, the time since their last meal, or the weather.

Oxford Risk is calling for increased use of technology and algorithms to help advisers deliver more consistent support to clients and avoid issues over assessments of risk tolerance and asset allocation.  It says the most effective noise cancelling remedy is to employ software to guide decisions, so they become more consistent.  Once a specific framework for the measurement of risk tolerance, risk capacity and other relevant factors is established it can be run at scale and speed, the report adds. 

Greg B Davies, PhD, Head of Behavioural Finance, Oxford Risk said: "Like the Decision Review System (DRS) used in cricket or the Television Match Official (TMO) in rugby, technology can be employed to greatly increase consistency and accuracy. 

"But in the end when the margins are extremely tight it should be the umpire's call. So should it be in the world of investment advice."

In the study, adviser characteristics seemed predictive of recommendations with university-educated advisers making lower risk assessments than average, while married advisers were lower risk than single advisers and those on salaries made higher risk recommendations than those on commission or fees.  Greg B Davies commented: "Identifying noise isn't about eradicating inconsistencies. It's about eradicating unjustifiable ones and evidencing justifiable ones."  

Oxford Risk, which builds software to help wealth managers and other financial services companies assist their clients in making the best financial decisions in the face of complexity, uncertainty, and behavioural biases, has developed a proprietary algorithm which ranks products, communications, and interventions for their suitability for each client at a particular time.

What do you think?

   Use "anonymous" as my name    |   Alert me via email on new comments   |   
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing

 



  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. KKR raises $6.4bn for the largest pan-Asia infrastructure fund[more]

    Laxman Pai, Opalesque Asia: The New York-based global investment firm KKR has raised a record $6.4bn for its second Asia-focused infrastructure fund, underlining investors' continued appetite for private markets. According to a media release from the alternative assets manager, the figure top

  2. Bucking the trend, top hedge fund makes plans for a second SPAC[more]

    From Institutional Investor: SPACs aren't dead. At least not to the folks at Cormorant Asset Management. The life sciences firm, whose hedge fund topped its peers in 2023, is confident it will match the success of its first blank-check company. Last week, the life sciences and biopharma speciali

  3. Benefit Street Partners closes fifth fund on $4.7 billion[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: Benefit Street Partners has closed its fifth flagship direct lending vehicle, BSP Debt Fund V, with $4.7 billion of investable capital across the strategy. Benefit Street invests primarily in privately originated, floating rate, senior secured loans. The fun

  4. 4 hedge fund themes that are working in 2024[more]

    From The Street: A poor earnings report from Tesla (TSLA) has not hurt the indexes on Thursday. The decline in Tesla stock, which is losing its position in the Magnificent Seven pantheon, is more than offset by strong earnings from IBM (IBM) and ServiceNow (NOW) . In addition, the much higher-t

  5. Opalesque Exclusive: A global macro fund eyes opportunities in bonds[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York for New Managers: Munich-based ThirdYear Capital rebounded in 2023, following a tough year for global macro. The firm's flagship ART Global Macro strategy finished the year up 1