Tue, Sep 28, 2021
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Industry Updates

PE firms criticized for not responding to triple crises of climate change, COVID-19, and racial injustice

Tuesday, November 17, 2020
Opalesque Industry Update - According to a new report about the private equity (PE) industry, the majority of PE firms are not doing enough to take systematic risks seriously in both their business operations and investment portfolios. The report, "Private Inequity: How the Private Equity Industry Needs to Improve When Addressing Systemic and Systematic Risks," analyzed how PE firms responded to the ongoing triple crises of climate change, the COVID-19 pandemic and racial injustice.

A research team analyzed 100 of the largest PE firms according to eight different categories or response types for a total of 2,400 potential responses (or 800 responses per crisis) that PE firms could have made between June 2019 and July 2020. Out of this total, researchers found publicly available evidence for only 264 responses (11.0%), suggesting a significant and urgent need for improvement. More than a third (38%) of reviewed PE firms took no public action of any kind in response to the crises.

The eight categories that were evaluated included two types of non-systemic responses (i.e., those unlikely to lead to systemic change and systematic risk management) and six types of systemic responses (i.e., those which would meaningfully contribute to systemic change and systematic risk management).

Non-systemic responses included:

  • Public statement - A PE firm recognizing there is a problem by issuing a public statement about a particular cause or issue
  • Donation - A PE firm giving back by donating to a nonprofit working to address one or more of these issues

Systemic responses included:

  • Internal changes - A PE firm self-reflecting on how it may be contributing to these issues and making changes to its internal business practices by (1) improving hiring and procurement practices, (2) improving employee training and resources, or (3) improving public reporting and disclosures
  • External changes - A PE firm acknowledging its role relative to systematic risks and making changes to its external investment processes by (1) launching new funds, committing more capital or engaging with portfolio companies to manage systematic risks, (2) aligning incentive and investment structures with stated ESG goals or targeted outcomes, or (3) aligning lobbying and political spending practices with ESG goals.

The most common responses, as a percentage of the potential response total (with 100% representing a perfect response rate), included: public statements (84/300, or 28.0%), donations (45/300, or 15.0%), internal changes (73/900, or 8.1%), and external changes (62/900, or 6.9%).

However, the frequency and types of responses varied greatly across the three crises. The COVID-19 pandemic elicited by far the most responses overall (114/800, or 14.3%), significantly outpacing both climate change (74/800, or 9.3%) and racial injustice (76/800, or 9.5%). COVID-19 is also unique in that it only surfaced as a crisis in late 1Q 2020, while both climate change and racial injustice have been recurring themes that seem to slip in and out of the public consciousness.

"Public statements and donations won't do anything to move the needle on these issues," said Dmitriy Ioselevich, CEO & Founder of 17 Communications and the lead author for the report. "To address the root causes of these crises, private equity firms need to move away from the 'thoughts and prayers' communications playbook and instead take tangible steps to manage and mitigate systemic risks. We need to see immediate change at both the firm-level and the investment-level to prevent these crises from snowballing out of control."

"While we recognize the private equity industry is responding to calls for stronger ESG integration, and many have taken steps in a positive direction, systemic crises demand timely action and less of a piecemeal approach," said Delilah Rothenberg, Executive Director of the Predistribution Initiative and a contributing author for the report. "Despite limited action to date, private equity firms are well-positioned to drive positive change given their ability to influence portfolio company governance, priorities, and even capital structures. To step up to the plate and demonstrate leadership, private equity investors need to conduct holistic assessments of their internal and external business practices to identify exposure and contributions to such risks, develop action plans with clear targets and timelines to close gaps, and communicate publicly about their ongoing progress."

The report also includes recommendations on specific actions that PE firms could take to address systemic and systematic risks, including:

  • Demonstrating that policies are supported with effective implementation (e.g., procedures, responsible parties, incentive structures, KPIs, targets and deadlines, grievance mechanisms, disclosure and accountability mechanisms, etc.)
  • Conducting third-party audits of existing practices
  • Integrating principles of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) into the firm and investment strategy, with a strong focus on racial justice
  • Adopting principles of predistribution to more adequately compensate workers and communities for the value that they create and the risk that they take
  • Disclosing political spend and lobbying activities

The full report is available at http://www.17c.org/private-inequity

What do you think?

   Use "anonymous" as my name    |   Alert me via email on new comments   |   
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. PE/VC: Climate tech is hot, but VCs can't forget about water, Five top trusts to tap into the private equity boom[more]

    Climate tech is hot, but VCs can't forget about water From Crunch Base: "It is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, oceans, and land." These fiery words come from the latest landmark U.N. report detailing intensifying, universal climate change impacts. They cover

  2. New Launches: H.I.G. closes first European buyout fund at $2.4bn, Cheyne Capital raises another $1.18bn credit fund to invest in struggling European companies, Falfurrias Capital Partners raises $850m in oversubscribed fund, Alan Howard-backed 10T raises $750m for debut crypto fund, Crayhill Capital strikes $820m hard cap close for second credit-focused fundraise, Edmond de Rothschild's Eres IV eyes second close in H1 2022, Revaia closes Europe's largest female-founded VC fund, Octopus unveils UK Future Generations sustainable fund, TrueBridge Capital Partners closes seed & micro-VC fund I, at $170m, Federated Hermes launches low-carbon bond fund with Swedish partner[more]

    H.I.G. closes first European buyout fund at $2.4bn From PIonline.com: H.I.G. Capital closed its first European middle-market buyout fund, the H.I.G. Europe Middle Market LBO Fund, at €2 billion ($2.4 billion), a news release shows. The fund targets middle-market companies prim

  3. U.S.: Peter Thiel gamed Silicon Valley, Donald Trump, and democracy to make billions, tax-free[more]

    From Bloomberg: The meeting started with a thank-you. President-elect Donald Trump was planted at a long table on the 25th floor of his Manhattan tower. Trump sat dead center, per custom, and, also per custom, looked deeply satisfied with himself. He was joined by his usual coterie of lackeys

  4. Opalesque Exclusive: Female led team of veteran ESG investors to launch debut fund[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York for New Managers: A female-led team of veteran ESG investors is preparing to launch a new fund early next year built on their ESG investing and advisory experience. Sustainable

  5. SPACs: After early investors flee SPAC deals, day traders rush in, PE-backed electric car maker Polestar worth $20bn in US SPAC deal, Europe's IPO market roars back to life but where are the SPACs?[more]

    After early investors flee SPAC deals, day traders rush in From WSJ: Day traders are targeting some companies that recently closed SPAC mergers, reinvigorating some of the meme-stock excitement that helped make such deals popular early in the year. The latest special-purpose-acquis