Fri, Mar 29, 2024
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Private Equity Strategies

As Cheap Money Reigns, Private Equity Investors Eye Risks

Friday, September 29, 2017

By: Bailey McCann, Private Equity Strategies

As private equity transactions hit 2007 levels, some investors are starting to worry about risk. According to a Financial Times report released yesterday, buyout values are up some 25 percent in the first half of the year and worldwide M&A activity is valued at $2.4 trillion year-to-date in 2017, an increase of two percent over last year. On the surface, it may seem like investors are poised to cash in, but easy financing has prompted some industry watchers to warn about risk.

Earlier this month, Tom Wyss, a Senior Consultant on Aon Hewitt’s private equity team wrote a short update on the growing use of lines of credit by GPs. He cautioned investors to take a closer look at the fine print during due diligence, as some GPs have started using lines of credit to finance operations and initial investments ahead of their first capital calls to investors. By calling capital later on in the process, GPs can inflate a fund's Internal Rate of Return (IRR), making it hard to assess performance.

"It is important to strip out the effect of credit lines when examining the performance of prior funds as usage will increase the IRR performance of prior funds both on an absolute and possibly on a relative basis," Wyss says, adding that when investors are assessing funds within the same vintage year, it is critical to note which firms use lines of credit and which do not, in order to maintain an apples to apples comparison.

Using lines of credit may also mean that GPs earn their carry sooner than they otherwise would. Typically, GPs gain access to carried interest once the IRR has cleared a certain threshold known as the hurdle rate. If a GP has used a line of credit early on in the fund lifecycle, he may make the hurdle rate faster without much in the way of real performance to show for it.

Peer pressure

As more GPs come to rely on lines of credit, it puts pressure on those that do not. Investment consultants often measure peer groups of funds using aggregate data, which could put GPs with lower initial IRRs at bottom of a group ranking, penalizing those GPs that don't use lines of credit at the start of a fund lifecycle. Investors have been dealing with a similar trend in the leveraged lending space for several years. So-called covenant-light loans have regained widespread use after hitting a brief speedbump during the immediate aftermath of the financial crisis. So much so, that a recent Bloomberg piece notes that there is now a stigma around safety. Investors use covenants as a check on the loan to ensure that they are repaid and so that they can step in if it starts to look like a company may default. In the current environment, if a deal comes through with covenants there is a concern that something is already wrong.

For investors in big funds and firms, the impact of these trends may be minimal as performance can be easier to assess and the risk of default is less likely. But in the mid-market and below, consultants like Aon's Wyss advise caution. In his update, Wyss says that investors may be able to guard against inflated IRR's by basing the hurdle rate on a combination of net fund level IRR and multiple. Clawback provisions should also be strengthened.

Investors also need to be very clear about what additional costs they might incur from fewer capital calls in the case of private equity funds and from fewer capital preservation rights in leveraged lending. If GPs move together when they do capital calls, investors could be faced with a significant outlay in order to meet requests that happened at the same time. There are also tax implications to consider if calls and distributions across funds start happening in lockstep. On the lending side, it may be more difficult for investors to recover losses if they bow to pressure to sign away covenant rights, especially in smaller companies where default risk is higher.

 
This article was published in Opalesque's Private Equity Strategies our monthly research update on the global private equity landscape including all sectors and market caps.
Private Equity Strategies
Private Equity Strategies
Private Equity Strategies


Today's Exclusives
Today's Other Voices
More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. KKR raises $6.4bn for the largest pan-Asia infrastructure fund[more]

    Laxman Pai, Opalesque Asia: The New York-based global investment firm KKR has raised a record $6.4bn for its second Asia-focused infrastructure fund, underlining investors' continued appetite for private markets. According to a media release from the alternative assets manager, the figure top

  2. Bucking the trend, top hedge fund makes plans for a second SPAC[more]

    From Institutional Investor: SPACs aren't dead. At least not to the folks at Cormorant Asset Management. The life sciences firm, whose hedge fund topped its peers in 2023, is confident it will match the success of its first blank-check company. Last week, the life sciences and biopharma speciali

  3. Benefit Street Partners closes fifth fund on $4.7 billion[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: Benefit Street Partners has closed its fifth flagship direct lending vehicle, BSP Debt Fund V, with $4.7 billion of investable capital across the strategy. Benefit Street invests primarily in privately originated, floating rate, senior secured loans. The fun

  4. 4 hedge fund themes that are working in 2024[more]

    From The Street: A poor earnings report from Tesla (TSLA) has not hurt the indexes on Thursday. The decline in Tesla stock, which is losing its position in the Magnificent Seven pantheon, is more than offset by strong earnings from IBM (IBM) and ServiceNow (NOW) . In addition, the much higher-t

  5. Opalesque Exclusive: A global macro fund eyes opportunities in bonds[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York for New Managers: Munich-based ThirdYear Capital rebounded in 2023, following a tough year for global macro. The firm's flagship ART Global Macro strategy finished the year up 1