Wed, Nov 18, 2026
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS pod
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Alternative Market Briefing

From the CBOE floor to KaiConvex - Noel Smith on carrying beta with less risk

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Matthias Knab, Opalesque for New Managers:

Last week Opalesque reported that Cem Karsan's Kai Asset Management is launching its first two hedge funds under the KaiConvex brand, run by former QVR Advisors portfolio managers Noel Smith and Scott Maidel (see the article here). In a follow-up conversation with Opalesque, Smith and Maidel explained where the edge in the two strategies comes from, what carries over from Smith's existing track record, and why they believe the hardest part of tail hedging is not buying the protection, but knowing what to do with it once it pays off.

Smith is the lead portfolio manager on both funds, with Maidel backing him up, while founder Cem Karsan focuses largely on the firm's media-facing work. The two commingled funds, KaiConvex Hedged Equity and KaiConvex Carry Neutral Tail Hedging, will be open for subscriptions on January 1, 2027, and subscription documents are being rolled out now.

From the CBOE floor to the screen

Smith, who also runs his own firm, Convex Asset Management, started out on the floor of the CBOE in 1996. "I was the initial seed capital behind the first real high frequency trading firm, Getco," he says. "Getco was kind of born out of my office - the guys that started it worked for me." Getco later combined with Knight Capital after Knight's 2012 algorithmic trading incident, and the merged business was eventually acquired by Virtu.

"So in terms of migrating from the floor and fractions to the screens and decimals, I've been there for the whole thing," Smith says. He has since operated in market making, proprietary trading and now hedge funds. "The point of these strategies is to bring best practices and some of that market wisdom into an investable product for investors."

Smith has known Karsan for about seven years and Maidel for five to six. The two worked together at QVR, where Maidel was head of business development and head of the hedge fund business. When QVR wound down, they decided to keep collaborating, and Kai turned out to be the natural home. "Frankly, it's fit to purpose," Smith says. "Scott has a lot of industry depth, he knows a lot about portfolio management and business development - and I think my business development skills could use some help. And Kai needed somebody to help run their strategies and introduce new ones. It was a meeting of the minds."

Hedged Equity: exploiting a structurally changed volatility surface

The Hedged Equity fund targets high risk-adjusted returns with a particular focus on up-down capture. According to Maidel, the edge rests on the boom in structured products, derivative income funds and option selling, and the structural change this has caused in the S&P 500 volatility surface.

"With buy-writes and all these products that are selling options for income, there is a natural selling that is necessarily depressing volatility at certain tenors," Smith explains. "So instead of having this large vol risk premium, it gets more and more narrow. If you can buy an option that will carry somewhat favorably over time, we think we can buy those options without the same risk profile you've had historically, and we can carry a beta with less risk."

The second idea behind the strategy is that volatility regimes are sticky. "Sometimes high vol will beget high vol," Smith says. "We think you can risk and de-risk opportunistically based on the vol regime." Using Delta One instruments, the fund is in the market more or less depending on how risky the team perceives it to be.

Maidel describes the program as "three layers deep". First, part of the equity beta is delivered through options and part through futures - buying calls rather than holding the index already cuts some of the downside. Second, a proprietary quantitative process using more than 40 signals drives how much beta the fund holds at any time. Third, an overlay of additional tail hedging, primarily VIX options but also long bond and gold options, provides further protection.

The strategy is predominantly derivatives-based, but also uses ETFs and futures. "We want to be flexible," Maidel says. "If we can get the right exposures using options, we always like to do that, because if there is a structural edge, we want to take advantage of it. You can't necessarily capture that edge simply by using a futures contract."

The track record

The Hedged Equity fund carries over Smith's track record, which goes back to 2017. Net of fees, the strategy has produced a positive up-down capture of 43, annualized volatility of about 10% and a compound annual growth rate of over 16% since inception, with a low maximum drawdown and a tame beta.

Up-down capture measures how much of the S&P 500's upside a program captures relative to how much of its downside. "Anything in the 30% to 40% range is simply an elite performance figure," Maidel says. "If you contrast this with other hedged equity programs, you'll notice that their up-down capture is often negative. If a program captures, say, 50% of the upside but 60% of the downside, that's minus 10."

Across his strategies, Smith currently has a couple of hundred million dollars in assets under advisement. He has run as much as USD600m and as little as a low seven-figure sum in the early days, but the trade logic has stayed the same. "Everything we're doing is very liquid, and there's no slippage. In other words, 10 million trades the same as 100 million, and 100 million trades the same as 500 million. Maybe not USD10 billion - but we've never been that large."

Almost all of the process is systematic. The only discretionary element is the monetization of hedges. "If we buy some puts, our puts are no different than anybody else's puts. We don't have any special VIX calls either," Smith says. "The art part of that trade is monetizing the hedges. But even there, it's more akin to a human in the loop than a human overriding signals." He compares it to a surgeon who collates the information from diagnostics and machines before acting.

Maidel puts the split at 80% to 90% systematic, with a layer of human risk management. "You never want to be 100% systematic. You always want that sanity check," he says. The Hedged Equity program is more systematic than the tail hedging program.

Carry Neutral Tail Hedging: "Everybody wants a hedge, nobody wants to pay for it"

"Everybody wants a hedge. Nobody wants to pay for it. So we're trying to strike a balance," Smith says of the second fund. The team surveyed what competitors have on offer and built the program around the most payoff for the least cost. Typically, part of the yield from T-bills or box spreads, plus an additional budget, is spent on instruments that rise when volatility rises.

Maidel summarizes the program in six sleeves: variance futures; S&P 500 options; VIX options, a significant component, using calls, call spreads and three-way structures such as selling a put to buy a call spread; high yield credit via HYG, typically puts and put spreads; long bonds via TLT; and gold via GLD, both typically calls and call spreads. The allocation among the sleeves is dynamic, and individual sleeves can be switched on or off when they become too expensive. "The question is always: where can we allocate to get the most convexity for the dollar spent?" Maidel says.

"The market goes down for different reasons at different times," Smith adds. "Just because the market goes down doesn't mean high yield spreads blow out - but sometimes they do."

Smith highlights one feature he says he rarely hears others discuss: combining VIX options with variance futures. "Variance is the square of volatility, so it has a different risk profile. Volatility has a linear return, variance has a convex return. If you couple those two things together, the chance that the market crashes and we don't make money is almost mathematically impossible. The only way that doesn't make money is if the market goes down very, very slowly - an extended, low volatility drawdown."

Putting on the hedges, Smith argues, is the easier part. "Any decent vol professional can identify relatively cheap spots on a vol surface. The harder part is knowing what to do on the other side of it. You've spent some money, you're in these hedges, and now you have a profit on the books. The VIX has gone from 12 to 32 - so what do you do? Is it 32 on the way to 52, or 32 on the way back to 12?"

The team scales out in tranches, guided by proprietary in-house tools. "The tail hedging strategy is basically a systematized way of doing what we would do at a prop desk when we have on a risky position and want to mitigate losses - but also not blow all of those returns if we are in the green on that trade," Smith says.

The Carry Neutral Tail Hedging fund has no prior commingled track record. However, Smith and Maidel have each managed custom institutional tail hedging overlays for more than 15 years, including very large and scalable derivative programs.

Anchor money, no seed deal

The commingled vehicles are domiciled in Cayman, and the team also offers separately managed accounts and funds of one for larger institutional investors. Each fund launches with between USD10m and USD20m of anchor money. "That is not a seed deal - there is no seed money or economics given away," Maidel says. Marketing started about a week ago, and he sees the offering as relevant for both institutional and retail investors.

Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing

 



  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Opalesque Exclusive: DACH institutions push alternatives to 32.3% of portfolios as hedge funds make a comeback[more]

    Matthias Knab, Opalesque for New Managers: Institutional investors in Germany, Austria and Switzerland now hold almost a third of their portfolios in alternative investments, and they are more confident than ever in

  2. KRX chief courts CalPERS for bigger bet on Korea[more]

    Korea Exchange Chairman and CEO Jeong Eun-bo held talks with California Public Employees' Retirement System, or CalPERS, to promote greater investment in South Korea's capital markets, the bourse operator announced Wednesday. Jeong met with CalPERS Chief Investment Officer Stephen Gilmore.

  3. 755 Unicorns, $8 Trillion: Fifth Era maps the autonomous digital economy[more]

    Matthias Knab, Opalesque for New Managers: Fifth Era Partners, a specialized asset manager focused on the convergence of Internet, AI/Agentic and Blockchain technologies, has released the findings of its 13th Bia

  4. Opalesque Exclusive: "Enough beta plays" - how Fasanara builds an alpha-only multi-strategy platform[more]

    Matthias Knab, Opalesque for New Managers: Most multi-strategy funds promise diversification. Fewer can explain why their return streams should stay independent when markets turn. In an Opalesque SkillsLab investor

  5. Opalesque Exclusive: Governance, Scale, and Boutique Resilience in a Consolidating Hedge Fund Industry[more]

    Matthias Knab, Opalesque for New Managers: The hedge fund industry has undergone significant consolidation in recent years, with capital increasingly concentrated among large multi-strategy platforms. Yet boutique m