|
|
Chris Addy By Chris Addy FCA CFA, Founder and CEO, Castle Hall Diligence:
Sam Bankman-Fried convicted on all counts - plenty to digest.
First, FTX strongly suggests that crypto - while a highly interesting concept and technology - is not yet ready for institutional investment.
Second, FTX raises profound questions around the venture capital investment model. For VC asset managers accepting institutional, pension capital - assets owned by tens (or hundreds) of thousands of end pension beneficiaries - a minimum standard of operational capability must be required before investing in target companies, even for early stage start ups.
In this case, FTX had an utterly deficient corporate infrastructure, including a lack of governance, a lack of a reputable audit, an entirely under qualified back office.
As VC learns from this example, what are the absolute minimums for any portfolio company investment?
- A capable finance function headed by a suitably experienced CFO
- Adequate accounting systems to ensure accurate recording of corporate transactions
- Clear segregation of duties to ensure that enigmatic 'founders' cannot over-ride core operational and business controls
- Effective controls around treasury and cash management
- Robust cyber security controls
VC firms may wish to invest in "founders" - but if they wish to do so with pension capital, they must ensure that portfolio companies adapt these basic criteria.
As a wise person recently said, "FOMO" is not an investment strategy.
|
|