Sat, Dec 4, 2021
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Alternative Market Briefing

Opalesque Webinar: So, when should you exit a manager?

Friday, March 13, 2020

Cedric Kohler
B. G., Opalesque Geneva for New Managers:

BlackRock Multi-Sector Income Trust recently fired one of its fund managers for conflict-of-interest after that manager loaned $75m to an indie film studio that cast his daughter in one of their movies, according to The Daily Mail and other papers. That is, for one, an unusual yet valid reason for firing a manager. Managers' reactions to the pandemic and the ensuing stock markets' freefall might be another. But what are the most common reasons for doing so?

Before you fire a manager, you need to define your performance success criteria, according to Cedric Kohler, partner at Fundana, a Geneva-based fund of hedge funds manager.

Do you have an absolute return target in mind or is it a relative to a benchmark, a portfolio or a peer group? How much of the performance should come from alpha versus beta? How much of the returns come from longs and from shorts? How much of the returns come from specific factors (such as momentum, growth, etc.)?

Furthermore, "every manager goes through a life cycle, and you need to be able to anticipate how things are going to turn out," he says during a recent on manager selection.

The typical reasons to fire a manager are:
- Change of manager
- Style drift
- Changes of terms
- Legal action
- Concentration ratio

As well as:
- Inability to understand performance drivers
- The portfolio becomes illiquid
- Rapid AuM growth. "Anything that grows to fast will be completely disrupted. We like to see our managers pause and digest growth by looking for other stocks, hiring more analysts, etc."

In general, try to look for anything that could change the portfolio manager's focus." It could be simple things like their organisation becoming more complex by for example managing more vehicles," he adds.

Manager selection is key

In the hedge fund world, there are challenges to sort through: a high degree of luck, a high degree of dispersion and a performance that is not usually persistent. So manager selection is key, he says.

Focusing on manager performance only does not allow allocators to differentiate skill from luck. Also, the performance numbers are not usually real. And beware of what looks too good to be true.

Looking only at the investment process is also a challenge. All of them make good sense. But one must be aware of manager behaviours, see how they will react to a market correction and a fund drawdown. What is portrayed on paper does not usually translate into reality.

As for themes, they always sound great, he continues. But "there is a world of difference between a great theme and a great performance. So we try to put that aside as much as we can."

Fundana's approach can be summed up as such: "We prefer facts over speech." It centers around three pillars:
(1) discover talent early (preferably more simple set-ups with a minimum of $200m);
(2) control the downside (with risk management tools and operational due diligence);
(3) ensure the upside (breaking down sources of performance and risks of AuM dilution).

Kohler wraps up by reminding us of the value of funds of funds (FoFs), the fallen funds of 2008. FoFs did not always add value before the crisis, he says. But a lot of clean-up has been done since then. Nowadays FoFs still make sense to some investors, because through FoFs, they get access to new managers; minimum investments are lower; FoFs have expertise and resources, such as dedicated staff and operations. FoFs can also provide special research for strategies that have high dispersion, as well as diversification with lower risks, and fee negotiations.

You can listen to a recording of the Skills lab webinar, Rethinking manager selection: skill or luck? (about 60 mins) here:

Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. SPACs: Trump-tied SPAC seeks Wall Street support, Nextdoor surges in public market debut after SPAC merger, Barrows Hotel Enterprises considers SPAC merger, Aussie SPAC targets big deal after NASDAQ IPO[more]

    Trump-tied SPAC seeks Wall Street support From Al Jazeera: Day traders and Reddit enthusiasts helped fuel a spectacular rally in Digital World Acquisition Corp shares, which reached a closing high of $94.20 last month before leveling out to recently trade around $60. The blank-ch

  2. Tiger funds change some stripes, Melvin Capital's comeback plan, What's behind Sachem Head's surge?, One of Asia's oldest hedge funds is buying distressed China debt[more]

    Tiger funds change some stripes From Institutional Investor: Falcon Edge, Light Street, Lone Pine, Viking, and Hound made significant buys and sells in the third quarter. Falcon Edge Capital Management exited its two largest U.S. long positions in the third quarter, according to

  3. SPACs: Hambro Perks eyes first London SPAC listing under new rules, SPACs churn out restatements, again, to correct accounting, Investment manager's SPAC Investcorp Europe Acquisition I files for a $250m IPO[more]

    Hambro Perks eyes first London SPAC listing under new rules From Bloomberg: U.K. venture capital firm Hambro Perks Ltd. aims to raise 140 million pounds ($187 million) listing a special purpose acquisition company in London, in what could be the market's first major blank-check offerin

  4. Opalesque Exclusive: TRF - the right product at the right time (part 1)[more]

    B. G., Opalesque Geneva: Eurex, an international derivatives exchange and a member of the Deutsche Börse Group, has been churning out its pioneering Total Return Futures (TRF) since 2016. In a

  5. Coinbase co-founder launches biggest VC fund in crypto, Valkyrie launches $100m DeFi hedge fund, Kyle Bass says the big money has been made in bitcoin[more]

    Coinbase co-founder launches biggest VC fund in crypto From the FT: Coinbase co-founder Fred Ehrsam and former Sequoia Capital partner Matt Huang have finished raising $2.5bn this month for Paradigm One, their first venture capital fund. Investors jockeyed to commit money to the fund, allo