Sun, May 27, 2018
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Index Track: You may be surprised at the variation in returns...

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Index Tracker

You May be Surprised at the Variation in Returns

Managed futures did phenomenally well in 2008, but exactly how well depends on which index you consult. Here is a selection of managed futures/commodity trading advisor indexes. The returns for the year range from around 10% to more than 20%--a significant range, with the high end of the spectrum about double the low end.

Indexes vary because databases from different vendors do not contain the same set of programs or managers. Databases vary in size as well, from a few hundred of CTA programs to thousands.

Another reason for the differences is methodology—some use assets under management to weigh funds in calculating the index, whereas others give all funds, large and small, equal weight. There are pros and cons for both methods and the choice depends on a user's needs. Using assets as weight means that the returns of larger programs dominate the index, which may work for users interested primarily in large programs but not for those assessing small ones.

The EDHEC index is not derived from a separate database but rather is a combination of several indexes. EDHEC, a French business school, calculates combination benchmarks using an analytical method to capture as much information as possible from available indexes, so the measure may represent a wider section of the industry.

Questions about index construction occur for all hedge fund strategies and even for widely used mainstream benchmarks—after all, even the Standard & Poor's 500 comes in market capitalization-weighed versus equal-weighted versions. Different indexes have advantages under different conditions.

Regardless of the index used, the fact remains that managed futures did spectacularly well compared to other investments. The only mainstream asset class that made gains high enough to be within the range of managed futures returns was—you guessed it, US Treasury bonds, with Barclays Capital US Treasury index making 13.7%.

2008 Performance
Barclay Hedge 14.6%
Credit Suisse/Tremont Managed Futures 18.3%
HedgeFund.Net CTA/MF Benchmark 12.2%
FTSE CTA MF Index 10.5%
Greenwich Futures 20.2%
Hennessy MF Index 16.2%
EDHEC CTA Global 15.6%
Other Asset Classes:
S&P 500 (-) 37%
MSCI EAFE (-) 43%
Barclays Capital US Aggregate Bond Index 5.2%
Barclays Capital US Treasury Index 13.7%



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Investing - Hedge funds hike Smurfit Kappa positions amid takeover deal hopes, Hedge fund IBV Capital digs deep to unlock long-term value in a competitive market, Eisman of 'The Big Short' fame recommends shorting Deutsche Bank[more]

    Hedge funds hike Smurfit Kappa positions amid takeover deal hopes From Irishtimes.com: Two US hedge funds, Davidson Kempner and York Capital, have accumulated a combined 4.74 per cent interest in cardboard box maker Smurfit Kappa using financial derivatives. It comes as many investors cl

  2. Foundations of hedge fund managers gave big to controversial donor-advised funds[more]

    In the world of philanthropy and tax-deductible charitable giving, the explosion of donor-advised funds has touched off intense debate. Now, there is evidence that the DAF boom is being further fuelled by hedge fund foundation money. Four of the top five foundations that gave the most to large do

  3. Third Point to raise $400 million for SPAC, Farley to run it[more]

    From Reuters.com: Daniel Loeb's hedge fund Third Point LLC plans to raise $400 million for a "blank check" company which will be run by outgoing stock market operator NYSE Group President Thomas Farley, according to a regulatory filing made on Tuesday. The new company, referred to on Wall Stre

  4. Study: For hedge funds, smaller is better[more]

    From Institutionalinvestor.com: The smaller the hedge fund is, the better its performance is likely to be, according to a new study. The study - "Size, Age, and the Performance Life Cycle of Hedge Funds," released April 26 - sought to determine whether a hedge fund's size and age had any effect on i

  5. Hedge fund returns rose in April for first gain since January[more]

    From Bloomberg.com: Bloomberg Hedge Fund Database shows returns flat this year - Currency strategies had the biggest monthly gain at 13% Hedge fund returns increased 0.78 percent in April, reversing two consecutive monthly declines. The swing of 134 basis points was driven by gains in all seven