Fri, Mar 31, 2017
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

May Ends Lower for Managed Futures with a Bang

Friday, June 28, 2013

By Mark Melin

May ended down broadly for managed futures, with the benchmark large cap Newedge CTA index ending down -1.72% with the broader and less discerning Barclay CTA Index -1.27%. What garnered media attention were the returns of some of the larger trend following CTAs, such as Graham Capital down -3.9%; Transtrend -3.1% and the financial heavy AHL down 10%.

For the institutional allocator it is important to understand not just what happened, but why it happened.

"Classic trend models are not build for a near zero yield environment," noted Andreas Clenow, author of Following the Trend and a principal at Zurich-based ACIES Asset Management. "The classic models will tell you to take larger and larger trades on the upside on every new peak. Those models are completely unaware of the asymmetric risk in that trade. A very limited upside and a massive downside."

Andreas Clenow, author of "Following The Trend," is also manager of the CTA Globalanced Systematic
Mr. Clenow, who will be speaking at the Battle of the Quants event in London June 26, notes the performance differential is based on the size of assets each fund is required to manage. "Smaller CTA hedge funds, like me, can try to adapt their models to this situation. The really large ones have a problem. If you're managing tens of billions, you'll essentially limited to rates and forex. I know, they all claim to do hundreds of market, but we can all do basic math here. There is no way that they could move enough to matter in most of those markets. So they're driven by two sectors, and one of them has had big blinking red warnings on it for some time. They're just too big to act on it."

Sources indicate that one of the larger trend following CTAs had recently changed risk management regimes where they no longer utilized intraday stop orders to scale out of positions, opting to exit all trades near the end of the trading day, which proved problematic when liquidating large positions in a volatile market. This CTA was adversely impacted by events in Japan and the sudden change in bond market trend dynamics.

In their blog, managed futures brokerage Attain Capital noted that the sheer size of their positions makes exiting positions quickly difficult - particularly when the algorithms the largest CTAs all send a sell signal at the same time. Covenent Capital, with over $300 million under management, reported returns of +4.89% in May and is up 10.19% year to date in its original program. The CTA's programs, which have been audited by the National Futures Association, have a track record dating back to 1999 and a compounded annual return of 13.64% with annualized volatility of 17.04%. The aggressive program, with a track record dating back to 2004, has a compounded annual return of +21.72% and annualized volatility of 20.60%.

Other well known trend following CTAs ended positive in May, including Estlander, which was up near +1.75%, while the majority ended lower.

Major Trend Followers

Performance Estimate Source: CTA independent reporting, Globalanced Systematic estimates and www.managedfuturesdatabase.com. Past Performance is not indicative of future results

Here is a key with Covenant and other "boutique" CTAs with near $500 million in AUM: Not only are they more nimble at entering and exiting markets, but they have a much wider choice in markets traded, benefiting from trends in commodity and niche financial markets that large CTAs can't practically enter.

But perhaps the most important consideration is that when a trend changes direction investors should expect losses regardless of the trend following program. Trend followers all capture the beta market environment of price persistence and when that price persistence ends in a given market, temporary losses are almost certain to follow. The alpha is in how the programs risk manage trend changes: some may utilize volatility based position scaling methods while other programs may simply absorb the losses in a temporary trend change anticipating the longer term trends remain intact, among many factors.

Institutional managers should recognize the risk management regime, trade hold period and markets traded of their investments to develop reasonably accurate performance and risk management metrics.

Spread Arbitrage / Relative Value Market Notes:

While trend traders had difficulty in May, certain relative value strategies showed signs of life. Emil van Essen, with $372 million in assets under management, was up 1.6% in May.

In general agricultural spread traders noted opportunity in soybean complex spreads as cattle and hog markets, while certain corn / soybean spreads started to look interesting.

As mentioned in the article above, markets have been trending below optimal levels.



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Opalesque Exclusive: FS Investments launches energy fund[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: $19 billion Philadelphia-based FS Investments has launched a new interval fund which will invest in energy. The FS Energy Total Return Fund is the firm's first closed-end interval fund and will invest opportunistically in energy companies and assets. FS

  2. Hedge fund liquidations in 2016 surpass 2009 levels, new launches decline[more]

    Benedicte Gravrand, Opalesque Geneva: Even as the hedge fund industry's total assets exceeded the $3tln milestone last year, hedge fund liquidations increased. So much so that 2016 had the highest number of liquidations since 2008, claims the latest HFR Market Microstructure Report, re

  3. Hedge funds find no joy in macro as returns lag Trump rally[more]

    From Gulfnews.com: In 2017, macro hedge funds were expected to shine. So far? Not so much. It's been a far from impressive first two months for funds that trade around macroeconomic events. Discretionary funds rose just 0.3 per cent through February, according to Hedge Fund Research Inc., while the

  4. Strategies - Billionaire investor Marc Lasry shares how he's playing markets right now, Classic models are failing FX hedge funds desperate for return[more]

    Billionaire investor Marc Lasry shares how he's playing markets right now From CNBC.com: Buy on the prospect of deregulation. Sell on the enactment of deregulation. That's the strategy that billionaire investor Marc Lasry is implementing, according to an interview with CNBC in Las Vegas

  5. Opalesque Exclusive: Aberdeen makes the case for the lower mid-market[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: Aberdeen Asset Management has released a new paper focused on lower mid-market private equity. According to the paper, this segment of the private equity market is gaining popularity with private equity investors that are looking for multiple expansion and less