Tue, Sep 23, 2014
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Discretionary Strategies In The Spotlight

Monday, April 22, 2013

By Mark Melin

Managed futures is typically an investment often perceptually correlated to mathematical probability and quantitative-based strategies. But there is a strong breed of manager, often taking a more traditional discretionary "hedge fund" approach to humanbased trade logic, who can provide interesting correlation benefits in a portfolio. This group of managers prove that it is not managed futures that provides the diversification, but rather the strategies the managers employ.

Discretionary managed futures strategies are those defined as using human-driven decision models or combining more than one strategy. Proprietary performance study benchmarks1 discretionary strategies as having the second lowest worst drawdown average, at 20.61%, compared to average trend following drawdown of 24.92%. Perhaps most interesting is the category's downside deviation, the sophisticated risk manager's look at how well a risk program operates during a relative crisis situation. Discretionary traders in this study had a downside deviation of 2.41%, on average, compared with a 3.08% downside volatility with trend following. (The strategy study referenced in this report is not designed to be definitive, but rather used as a guidepost for relative value analysis. See footnote for study details.)

Former Commodity Corporation executive Lee Gladden, now chief executive officer at Witherspoon Asset Management, discusses correlation risk in a single strategy portfolio.

Based on its variety in approach, discretionary trading lacks a direct correlation to any single market environment. Price persistence, volatility, and mean reversion do not always correlate directly to a discretionary or tactical approach to the markets, making it difficult to identify beta market exposure.

Discretionary traders produced interesting relative downside volatility numbers and as a general category measured in this limited study, they have controlled loss size to a greater degree in the past. Based on the study average loss size in this category was 2.85% while 3.63% was the average in the trend following category. While such studies of performance are not empirically definitive, they do provide insight into risk management protocols one might consider when evaluating and managing the investment going forward.

Trend following typically makes up nearly 70% of all core strategy types in manged futures. Enter Witherspoon Asset Management, a group of former Commodity Corporation executives who launched a managed futures mutual fund targeted to provide a multi-strategy portfolio of managers averaging 75% discretionary and tactical specialists and 25% systematic / trend following.

It is for this reason Witherspoon's recently launched Managed Futures Strategy Fund (ticker: CTAAX, CTAIX) is interesting. Over 90% of single manager managed futures mutual funds significantly favor trend following.

"Discretionary sources of alpha are underrepresented in the current managed futures funds," said Lee Gladden, who has over 30 years experience in managed futures which began with Commodities Corporation (now Goldman Sachs Hedge Fund Strategies Group) in 1981

Witherspoon's focus on discretionary traders and tactical specialists (i.e. non trend-following) dates back to the culture and legacy of Commodities Corporation in Princeton, a history which most of the Witherspoon management team shares. Commodities Corporation was well known as a breeding ground for some of the legendary traders in the industry, including Paul Tudor Jones, Louis Bacon, and Bruce Kovner.

"The biggest limitation facing a portfolio composed primarily of trend following managers is that most such managers tend to exhibit high degrees of correlation with one another," Gladden adds.

Gladden explains the difference. "Witherspoon usually allocates approximately 75% of the capital in its portfolio to managers who are not trend followers and who have a low correlation with each other. As a result, we believe our portfolio is designed to have less volatility and to be more consistent. Currently we have two trend-followers and seven discretionary traders/tactical specialists in our CTA portfolio."

1. Risk Disclosure / Footnote: Averaged CTA performance is not being represented as reflective of individual performance. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Performance Source: HPMF Strategy Benchmark Performance Study was referenced in this article, 2010 (Wiley). The study on Page 239 was conducted by averaging the performance of all managed futures programs with a 36 month track record or longer reporting to the BarclayHedge CTA database at the time of the reporting period. Spot checking of the study has occurred since 2010 but no inclusive study of the topic has taken place since that point.



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. SEC charges 19 investment firms and one trader for breach of Rule 105[more]

    Benedicte Gravrand, Opalesque Geneva: The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) started a push to enhance the enforcement of Rule 105 of Regulation M last year to uncover hedge funds and private equity firms that have illegally participated in an offering of a stock after short selling it duri

  2. Fund managers, bullish on Europe, anticipate monetary policy separation of Fed and ECB[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: At least 202 fund managers with $556bn of assets under management said that while the European Central Bank (ECB) has eased its monetary policy that sent sentiments towards Europe to pick up, the Fed is expected to hike its rate in the spring of 2015. Investor

  3. Institutions - North Carolina workers call on state pension to dump up to $6bn in hedge funds, UK pension fund criticizes hedge fund fees[more]

    North Carolina workers call on state pension to dump up to $6bn in hedge funds From Forbes.com: The State Employees Association of North Carolina this afternoon called on state Treasurer Janet Cowell to withdraw all investments in hedge funds, which appear to amount to approximately $6 b

  4. News Briefs - Limited partners of investment managers may be subject to self-employment taxes, Just one week left until NYC's Rocktoberfest[more]

    Limited partners of investment managers may be subject to self-employment taxes On September 5, 2014, the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) issued Chief Counsel Advice 201436049, concluding that members of an investment manager were subject to self-employment taxes with respect to their e

  5. Institutions - Adviser's faith in hedge funds unshaken by CalPERS' move Advisers weigh in on CalPERS’ decision, Gina Raimondo sees no reason to follow California’s lead, exit hedge funds, Danish pension funds step up 'alternative investments'[more]

    Adviser's faith in hedge funds unshaken by CalPERS' move From WSJ.com: Financial advisers who use hedge funds in their clients' portfolios say they aren't rethinking that approach after a huge California pension fund announced plans to exit the hedge-fund market. The decision by the Cali