Sun, May 20, 2018
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

The Untold Story: Serious Issues With Chairman Gensler's Role in MF Global's Demise
Not only has this chairman governed during the most damaging event in regulated derivatives market history, did inaction at key points assist in the destruction?

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Serious Issues With Chairman Gensler's Role in MF Global's Demise

By Mark Melin

CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler has thusfar refused independent questioning from those with intimate knowledge of the MF Global affair. Serious questions exist regarding Mr. Gensler's oversight not only as the commodity markets suffered their worst set back in history, but his potential role in assisting in this process.

Did MF Global's Sovereign Debt Positions Vaporize During the Sale?

A serious question that should be asked of Mr. Gensler involves the foreign sovereign debt positions held by MF Global. Did MF Global have the sovereign debt positions on their books during the sale process, or were those positions removed from the books? If removed, why did those positions not get packaged in the original sale of the broker? The buyers were said to be interested. Shouldn't the CFTC Chairman do everything possible to help facilitate the sale of MF Global?
Additional questions center on the Chairman's activities over the Halloween weekend.

During an event with profound impact on market integrity, normal protocol would be for Chairman Gensler to consult domain experts and career staff regarding the implications of a bankruptcy decision. The Chairman's actions did not to follow anticipated protocol and resulted in decisions being made regarding abdicating responsibility of the bankruptcy process. An investigation into CFTC procedures would document that actions that impact the stability or integrity of markets are typically considered in conjunction with staff. At a minimum, Chairman Gensler could have reached out to the domain regulators and career staff to mention what was about to occur regarding the bankruptcy process.

Questions that might be asked of Mr. Gensler include: "When control of the bankruptcy process was succeeded to the SEC in the early morning meeting of October 31, 2011, why didn't you consult career staff or fellow regulators? The bankruptcy process could have waited several hours, at a minimum. The event had historic impact on commodity market integrity, your sworn duty to uphold. At a minimum this is neglect or more seriously a breach of fiduciary responsibility.

During the period of time Chairman Gensler managed the MF Global process, until November 3, 2011, serious questions were raised. MF Global had violated segregation levels in July, 2011 and the manipulation of disclosure documents to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over the summer of 2011 obfuscated critical risk disclosure in MF Global's bond offering. A CFTC Commissioner called for an investigation into this behavior, but his calls went ignored by officials.
The question for Chairman Gensler: What was the conflict of interest you cite as your reason for a partial recusal from the MF Global affair? When calls from a CFTC commissioner identified potential fraudulent behavior in a document scandal, was this considered a red flag scratching the surface of numerous fraud suspicions?

What to Expect from the Congressional Report on MF Global


On Thursday, November 15 at 10:30 AM the Congressional report on MF Global is set to be released.

The report is not expected to provide any clarity towards criminality, as Congress is unlikely to interfere with an ongoing investigation. The report will likely focus on MF Global risk management, lack of controls and document "chaos" and "confusion" in the bankruptcy process has been widely reported. The report will engage in a review of regulatory discussions and provide a review of certain regulatory expectations. A review of both CFTC and CMEGroup performance may be included, but the report won't address what should or should not have been done. It is unknown the extent to which the actions of November 1, 2011 will be addressed in the report.

Overall the report's tone is anticipated to be similar to the bankruptcy trustee's report in that it will document facts, identifying potential areas of concern. Unfortunately, some areas of concern could be addressed using nuanced statements and references. Don't expect the report to provide any clear smoking guns - particularly as it relates to the guilt of Jon Corzine, MF Global's acknowledged leader.



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. News Briefs - Warren Buffett: Target date funds aren't the way to go, Cambridge Analytica could be reborn under a different name[more]

    Warren Buffett: Target date funds aren't the way to go Planning for retirement can be complicated and stressful. This is why target date funds - funds that are managed based on when you expect to retire - are so attractive. Over time, the balance of stocks, bonds and cash evolve automati

  2. Investing - Hedge funds hike Smurfit Kappa positions amid takeover deal hopes, Hedge fund IBV Capital digs deep to unlock long-term value in a competitive market, Eisman of 'The Big Short' fame recommends shorting Deutsche Bank[more]

    Hedge funds hike Smurfit Kappa positions amid takeover deal hopes From Irishtimes.com: Two US hedge funds, Davidson Kempner and York Capital, have accumulated a combined 4.74 per cent interest in cardboard box maker Smurfit Kappa using financial derivatives. It comes as many investors cl

  3. Foundations of hedge fund managers gave big to controversial donor-advised funds[more]

    In the world of philanthropy and tax-deductible charitable giving, the explosion of donor-advised funds has touched off intense debate. Now, there is evidence that the DAF boom is being further fuelled by hedge fund foundation money. Four of the top five foundations that gave the most to large do

  4. Study: For hedge funds, smaller is better[more]

    From Institutionalinvestor.com: The smaller the hedge fund is, the better its performance is likely to be, according to a new study. The study - "Size, Age, and the Performance Life Cycle of Hedge Funds," released April 26 - sought to determine whether a hedge fund's size and age had any effect on i

  5. Hedge fund returns rose in April for first gain since January[more]

    From Bloomberg.com: Bloomberg Hedge Fund Database shows returns flat this year - Currency strategies had the biggest monthly gain at 13% Hedge fund returns increased 0.78 percent in April, reversing two consecutive monthly declines. The swing of 134 basis points was driven by gains in all seven