Tue, Feb 21, 2017
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Index Tracker: Long commodities vs. managed futures: what the indexes say.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Long Commodities vs. Managed Futures

In the previous section, Ira Kawaller argues that long-only commodities do not on the whole add to a portfolio's return over the long term. This is an ongoing debate of increasing importance as long-only commodity index investments grow.

As far as index data goes, long commodities make big returns at times and big losses at other times. The past few months demonstrated this. In September, the S&P Goldman Sachs Commodity Index gained 9.4%, but that was after losing almost 5% in August. By contrast, managed futures returns were solid for both months (Chart 1). One notices hat managed futures is less volatile and tends to vary within a narrower range.

CHART 1 Long Commodities vs. Managed Futures in Recent Months

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

September August
Dow Jones Credit Suisse Managed Futures 2.8% 4.9%
DJ-UBS Commodity Index 7.3% -2.6%
S&P Goldman Sachs Commodity Index 9.4% -4.9%

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Look back over the years and you see a similar pattern. A long-only commodity index like the S&P GSCI can make the outsized gains, like the 33% it returned in 2007. Managed futures indexes do not show that kind of profit even in very good years, although individual CTAs can have very high returns.

On the other hand, the S&P GSCI went down by 47% in 2008, while managed futures proved its ability to act as a hedge in a market downturn (Chart 2).

The key issue is preserving capital. Long-only commodities lose so much in bad years, an investor that stays with a commodity index-based fund has less capital to take advantage of the surges. Not so with a diversified portfolio of managed futures programs. Losses are muted - so more of a long-term investor's capital is preserved for making money when market conditions favor the strategy.

CHART 2



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. With $54bn in assets, Philippines is ready for hedge funds, alternative investment products[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: With the country's outstanding fund management industry at $54bn and growing, the Philippine market and its investors are ready to invest in "more sophisticated" asset management products, like hedge funds and alternative investments, said Deanno J. Basas, presi

  2. SoftBank to buy Fortress Investment for $3.3bn[more]

    From Reuters.com: Japan's SoftBank Group Corp on Wednesday said it has agreed to buy Fortress Investment Group LLC for about $3.3 billion, looking to add investment expertise as it prepares to launch the world's largest private equity fund. The all-cash deal is SoftBank's first major investmen

  3. ...And Finally - Truth in advertising[more]

    From Newsoftheweird.com: Girl Scout Charlotte McCourt, 11, of South Orange, New Jersey, saw her sales zoom recently when she posted "brutally honest" reviews of the Scouts' cookies she was selling -- giving none of them a "10" and labeling some with dour descriptions. She was hoping to sell

  4. Europe - Brexit - Updated legal guide, Euro exchange rates set to tumble as hedge fund's super computer predicts Marine Le Pen will be next French president, Swiss fund market hits all-time high[more]

    Brexit - Updated legal guide From Herbertsmithfreehills.com: When we began analysing in depth the possibility of Britain exiting the EU (Brexit), 18 months prior to the June 2016 referendum, the business consensus was very much that Brexit was a remote prospect that either would never hap

  5. People - Gramercy appoints Bradshaw McKee as managing director of Capital Solutions, Trump taps Cerberus's Feinberg to lead intelligence review[more]

    Gramercy appoints Bradshaw McKee as managing director of Capital Solutions Gramercy Funds Management LLC, a $5.8 billion dedicated emerging markets investment manager, today announced the appointment of Bradshaw McKee to the position of Managing Director, Capital Solutions and Distressed