Sat, Jun 23, 2018
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Futures Lab: New handbook by Mark Melin offers comprehensive guidelines for managed futures investing, including ways to deal with risk.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Nuts and Bolts for Investors
By Chidem Kurdas

Just in time to meet the growing interest in managed futures, there's a new handbook for investors, High-Performance Managed Futures: The New Way to Diversify Your Portfolio by Mark Melin (Wiley, 2010). Below is a review and some highlights, in particular on how investors can control specific risks.

Mr. Melin is a director at PFG Best, a futures commission merchant. He's written and edited other books, including The Chicago Board of Trade Handbook of Futures and Options.

In the new book, he points out that assets have grown 700% in 10 years, yet managed futures remains something of a mystery to the investing public. "It is amazing that managed futures is one of the fastest growing asset classes and yet it remains relatively unknown and misunderstood," he says.

The book starts with an overview, which will be useful to beginner investors, and a description of the regulatory system. There is an excellent chapter on volatility, arguing that volatile but uncorrelated investments can be used to reduce the volatility of the overall portfolio - as pioneering research by Lintner and Markowitz showed.

Mr. Melin explains the managed futures account structure and how it protects investors, how to establish performance and risk targets and how to identify successful commodity trading advisors and construct a portfolio of them. He discusses reward-adjusted deviation, principal-protected investments and a variety of related subjects.

His opinions are a useful part of the discussion, though not everybody will agree with him on every topic.

Thus the chapter on risk not only lays out various hazards in managed futures investing but also Mr. Melin's useful comments on each and suggested ways of avoiding bad outcomes. He identifies three basic categories of risk, or choke points (Table 1). Of these, he sees individual manager risk as presenting the most significant problem.

TABLE 1

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Three Major Choke Points

Risk Comment How to Control
Unmonitored Margin and Leverage most common watch margin-to-equity ratio

Individual Manager

most significant avoid concentration
Fraud most preventable get segregated account

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Source: High-Performance Managed Futures, discussion in chapter 11.

Individual manager risk is a catchall bucket that includes all decisions made by a CTA. It ranges from the time frame of trade execution to business operations. Mr. Melin occasionally describes this as unsupervised manager risk, but a CTA might have the wrong time frame for tracking a trend, for instance, and make a loss, no matter how carefully the clients watch their investments.

As he notes, the source of individual manager risk is concentration in a single CTA program or an undiversified portfolio of CTAs. Hence investing in a group of CTAs with diverse strategies and performance characteristics is the way to manage the risk. Mr. Melin compares multi-manager CTA portfolios to a single top-performing CTA to illustrate the power of diversification (Table 2). The drawdowns and risk-adjusted returns (Sharpe ratios) tell the story.

TABLE 2

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hypothetical Combinations of CTAs vs. Single CTA

Compounded Annual Return Worst Drawdown Sharpe Ratio
Conservative portfolio 7.7% 6.6% 0.85
Aggressive portfolio 35% 32% 1.02
Top CTA 22.6% 43% 0.43

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Source: High-Performance Managed Futures, p. 44.

Most of the writing in the book is clear and straightforward, if not very engaging. This is not light reading. It requires patience, attention to numbers and willingness to follow abstract arguments. A website, www.wiley.com/go/managedfutures contains much useful material and is to be updated regularly.

None of the points made in the book will surprise seasoned managed futures investors, but this wide-ranging primer should be a valuable resource for newcomers to the industry.



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Paper: The performance of stocks actively pitched by hedge funds[more]

    Using a novel dataset drawn from investment conferences from 2008 to 2013, I show that hedge funds take advantage of the publicity of these conferences to strategically release their book information to drive market demand. Specifically, hedge funds sell pitched stocks after the conferences to ta

  2. North America - US fundraising for special purpose acquisition vehicles hits record this year[more]

    From AFR.com: Special purpose acquisition vehicles (spacs) are hitting the US market at the fastest rate on record, attracting the likes of Goldman Sachs and hedge fund investor Daniel Loeb for the two largest such deals in 2018. Spacs have raised $US4.5bn so far in 2018, the largest amount fo

  3. Investing - Man Group and AQR try to take aim at private equity industry, Hedge funds poised to be winners in AT&T-Time Warner deal[more]

    Man Group and AQR try to take aim at private equity industry From FT.com: The popularity of private equity investments has prompted asset managers such as Man Group and AQR to devise strategies that aim to replicate PE returns but at a much lower cost to investors. Both companies a

  4. News Briefs: David Stemerman's hedge fund holdings shrank before his run for governor, nvestment manager TSW triggers succession plan, Alan Howard joins Peter Thiel investing in Cologne-based fintech startup[more]

    David Stemerman's hedge fund holdings shrank before his run for governor But the U.S. holdings of Stemerman's Greenwich hedge fund, Conatus Capital, shrank from $2.6 billion at the apex to just over $1 billion before he announced his move into politics. (Hartford Courant) Inv

  5. British Empire: Pershing's 23% discount 'unsustainable'[more]

    From Citywire: The wide discount on Pershing Square Holdings (PSH) is 'unsustainable' and puts star hedge fund manager Bill Ackman under pressure, says British Empire (BTEM). Pershing is the third largest holding in the £850 million British Empire trust, managed by Joe Bauernfreund, which sp