Sun, Mar 1, 2015
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Regulators & Courts: Futures vs. securities regulation: Can harmony be achieved?

Thursday, October 15, 2009

In Search of Harmony

Coordinating the oversight of futures and securities markets is on the agenda as Congress moves from medical insurance legislation to financial regulation. But it is not clear how and to what extent this will be done.

Among those calling for changes is Duncan Niederauer, the chief executive of NYSE Euronext. "We're still concerned with gaps in SEC and CFTC regulation," he said at a September 24th conference of the Investment Company Institute, the mutual fund trade association.

He argued for the regulation of over-the-counter derivatives and the so-called dark pools, private trading venues that have increasingly attracted hedge funds and mutual funds-taking away business from regulated exchanges such as the NYSE.

While many people in Washington think the equity market is a bastion of transparency and regulation, he says, in reality 40% of trading is opaque and largely unregulated, with private pools that do not display quotes and liquidity. He said NYSE pays 80% of compliance costs and can't tolerate different regulatory burdens; there has to be a one-level playing field.

Futures exchanges themselves are not seen as a problem. Walt Lukken, senior vice president at NYSE, said that they don't see systemic risk in futures markets where hedge funds are trading. These markets continued to function during the 2008 crisis and were not a problem.

Nevertheless, there are questions about the separate oversight of futures and securities markets. Arguments for consolidating regulation address the need to fill what are seen as regulatory gaps. But merging the Commodity Futures Trading Commission with the Securities and Exchange Commission, as recommended by the US Treasury last year, now appears to be unlikely.

Disparate Missions

Few people appreciate the differences between securities and futures, says Erik Sirri, a former director of the SEC Division of Trading and Markets and currently professor of finance at Babson College. It is more complicated than just merging agencies because the underlying markets and laws are different, he suggested at the ICI conference.

One sharp distinction is that professional traders dominate futures markets, whereas retail investors are a big part of the stock market. The markets perform different functions. Futures markets do not raise capital for companies, instead they enable the shifting of risk to those willing to take it and the determination of prices.

These market characteristics make for distinct regulatory missions. The SEC focuses on investor protection while the CFTC's priority is the working of the market. Mr. Sirri said that innovation is easy in futures-a new contract can be introduced quickly and if it does not work, it disappears. So products come and go all the time. By contrast, the SEC takes the opposite approach, taking time to consider a product's design and how investors will fare with it.

One result of this divergence: getting approval for options on exchange-traded funds took years. The CFTC saw these as a commodity options but the SEC regarded them as securities options, since ETFs trade on the NYSE.

Chart a Path

Another area where the dissimilar missions show up is when a trader, such as a hedge fund, fails. The SEC wants to freeze the assets by way of protecting customers, but from the CFTC point of view, that will disrupt trading and may threaten systemic market integrity.

Flash orders, which the SEC has moved to ban, is another point of difference. The SEC regards it as unfair that flash orders allow one group to get information not available to others. But for the futures market, this is not an issue.

Mr. Sirri argues that even if the agencies were merged, these differences would remain within the single organization. He favors harmonizing regulations now while leaving the option of agency integration down the road, as the issues are worked through.

So far the Obama administration does not appear to have specific suggestions. A white paper calls on the SEC and the CFTC to chart a path to harmonization and joint regulation but there are a host of issues, says Jeffrey Brown, senor vice president at Charles Schwab & Co.



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Investing - Seth Klarman of Baupost outlines his investment process as major stock market indices are stretched, Myriad hedge fund sold bulk of its Alibaba stake last year[more]

    Seth Klarman of Baupost outlines his investment process as major stock market indices are stretched From Valuewalk.com: As hedge fund manager Seth Klarman, leader of the $28 billion Baupost Group, reviews 2014 performance and considers investors gained near 7 percent on the year, he cons

  2. Adamas Asset Management and Ping An Insurance to co-manage $500m debt fund[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: Hong Kong-based Adamas Asset Management and Ping An Insurance Group, one of China’s largest financial institutions, have finalized a memorandum of und

  3. Opalesque Exclusive: dbSelect’s top ten FX strategies average almost 10% in January[more]

    Benedicte Gravrand, Opalesque Geneva: In one of Deutsche Asset & Wealth Management (AWM)’s hedge fund platforms, called dbSelect, a number of FX Strategies did very well in January. dbSelect is a managed investment platform for unf

  4. Opalesque Exclusive: SEC’s Mark J. Flannery warns hedge funds against valuation misconduct[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: Securities and Exchange Commission chief economist and director of Division of Economic and Risk Analysis (DERA) Mark J. Flannery has warned of the risks posed by market misconduct, particularly in the true valuation of assets by hedge fund managers. In his

  5. Dymon Asia's $3bn macro hedge fund lost 10.45% in January[more]

    From Reuters.com: Dymon Asia's $3.1 billion macro hedge fund lost 10.45 percent in January, performance data seen by Reuters showed, a month where many peers lost heavily after a surprise rise in the Swiss franc. Singapore-based Dymon, set up by Danny Yong, a former founding partner and chie