Thu, Sep 18, 2014
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Industry Updates

Spring Mountain Capital: Big hedge funds more vulnerable

Friday, November 12, 2010
Opalesque Industry Update – The bigger they are, the harder they fall.

A new study by Spring Mountain Capital, LP (SMC), a New York-based investment management firm with $2bn in AuM and advisory, has shown that bigger hedge funds tend to generate lower alpha than smaller funds and will exploit market volatility to a weaker degree than do smaller funds.

At the same time, the proprietary white paper titled “The Relation Between Hedge Fund Size and Risk,” which studied data from 7,545 existing funds (as well as 8,916 hedge funds that have seized to exist), also showed that large funds compensate for their lower alpha and inability to exploit volatility by having higher beta.

“Large hedge funds may be perceived as less risky than smaller ones, but our research and experience suggests that this focus may be misplaced; and in the future, the opportunity costs of investing in large funds may be higher and the safety benefit of investing in large funds may be lower than investors currently expect,” said Jason Orchard, co-author of the white paper and a Principal at SMC. Haim Mozes, Ph.D, a senior consultant with SMC and an Associate Professor of Accounting at Fordham University in New York, co-authored the study.

The two researchers concluded that investors have misconceptions regarding investing their money with large hedge funds because they are drawn to a false safety and liquidity advantages. But Orchard and Mozes said they identified a number of factors that increase a large fund’s risk profile relative to its smaller peers. Managers of large funds are confident that good performance will be maintained, therefore warding off investor redemptions, but “eventually, fund size will hinder performance enough to trigger a redemption cycle that has a strong negative feedback loop.”

Key highlights of the study
• Large funds have the ability to sustain poor performance before closing for a longer period of time than do small funds.

• Large funds typically underperform their peer group for more than three years prior to closing and a decline in fund-raising typically precedes a fund’s performance decline. For smaller funds, the decline in fund raising typically follows a decline in performance.

• In current markets, funds in the 90th percentile of reported assets under management (approximately $750M) offer very little marginal benefit from increased size.

“Ultimately the research concludes that very large hedge funds may eventually have to transition to a private equity model, where capital is locked up for long periods of time, or to an investment banking model, in which capital is permanent and accessible via the public markets, in order to avoid closing,” said Mozes added.

Spring Mountain’s research is contrary to conventional wisdom
SMC’s study if proved correct, should concern investors that allocated their money to larger and more established hedge funds.

In September, Absolute Return (AR) released a study that showed the largest U.S. hedge funds, led by the $51-bn Bridgewater Associates, secured the largest inflows in the first half of 2010 compared with rivals. The firm piled up an additional $7.3bn in new money or an increase of 17% in its AuM, the biggest gain in 2010.

Other large hedge funds that reported inflows were JP Morgan's asset management unit with $2.7bn inflows (raising its assets to $41bn); George Soros' Soros Fund Management; Och-Ziff Capital Management Group; BlackRock; Angelo, Gordon & Co; Seth Klarman's Baupost Group, and Thomas Steyer's Farallon Capital Management. Each firm manages $20 billion or more, the AR Magazine reported.

In an interview with Matthias Knab of OpalesqueTV in September, Narayan Naik, Professor at the London Business School and Director of the Hedge Funds Centre, also noted that hedge funds of funds’ allocations to bigger funds are increasing.

Naik told Opalesque that he tracked the concentration of assets across fund managers from the year 2000 through December 2009 and found that the concentration continue to increase over that time, and grew from the top 10% of managers overseeing 75% of the hedge fund industry's assets to the top 10% of managers overseeing 85% of the hedge fund industry's assets (See Opalesque Exclusive: here).

Last month, Hedge Fund Research reported that almost all new capital inflows from investors were concentrated to large hedge funds, particularly with more than $1bn in assets. Data from HFR revealed that large hedge funds control at least 60% of all hedge-fund assets.

PerTrac: small to mid-sized hedge funds outperformed in 2009
The findings of Spring Mountain’s research is corraborated with the independent study made by financial service provider PerTrac Financial Solutions which released its own research in late October reaffirming the existing trends that small to mid-sized funds outperformed their larger peers in 2009.

“Coming off the worst calendar year losses in history in 2008, the hedge fund industry provided investors with a strong comeback in 2009. According to our research, the rally was led by the younger funds,” said Jeff Hendren, Co-President of PerTrac. “When we looked at performance according to the size of a fund, our research revealed that the small and mid-sized funds achieved the highest performance. These two findings are likely related because fund size tends to correlate with fund tenure.”
- Precy Dumlao
PD

What do you think?

   Use "anonymous" as my name    |   Alert me via email on new comments   |   
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. SEC charges 19 investment firms and one trader for breach of Rule 105[more]

    Benedicte Gravrand, Opalesque Geneva: The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) started a push to enhance the enforcement of Rule 105 of Regulation M last year to uncover hedge funds and private equity firms that have illegally participated in an offering of a stock after short selling it duri

  2. Fund managers, bullish on Europe, anticipate monetary policy separation of Fed and ECB[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: At least 202 fund managers with $556bn of assets under management said that while the European Central Bank (ECB) has eased its monetary policy that sent sentiments towards Europe to pick up, the Fed is expected to hike its rate in the spring of 2015. Investor

  3. Investors looking at other sources for hedge fund-like returns[more]

    Komfie Manalo, Opalesque Asia: Investors who are always on the lookout for higher gains are looking at alternative sources of income, particularly exchange-traded fund industry that generates hedge fund-like returns, according to

  4. News Briefs - Limited partners of investment managers may be subject to self-employment taxes, Just one week left until NYC's Rocktoberfest[more]

    Limited partners of investment managers may be subject to self-employment taxes On September 5, 2014, the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) issued Chief Counsel Advice 201436049, concluding that members of an investment manager were subject to self-employment taxes with respect to their e

  5. Institutions - Adviser's faith in hedge funds unshaken by CalPERS' move Advisers weigh in on CalPERS’ decision, Gina Raimondo sees no reason to follow California’s lead, exit hedge funds, Danish pension funds step up 'alternative investments'[more]

    Adviser's faith in hedge funds unshaken by CalPERS' move From WSJ.com: Financial advisers who use hedge funds in their clients' portfolios say they aren't rethinking that approach after a huge California pension fund announced plans to exit the hedge-fund market. The decision by the Cali