Fri, Apr 25, 2014
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Industry Updates

Elliott Associates drops court case against AR magazine

Wednesday, September 01, 2010
Opalesque Industry Update – Portland, Oregon-based hedge fund firm Elliott Associates announced on Tuesday (August 31) it was dropping its court case against trade publication Absolute Return (AR) magazine, formally ending a legal saber-rattling between a hedge fund firm and advocates of the First Amendments or the right to free speech, said The New York Observer.

Elliott’s move came two days before AR Magazine was scheduled to submit its response before the New York State Supreme Court over the hedge fund’s petition to compel AR to reveal the source of a news article regarding the fund’s quarterly performance.

John Pelosi, a partner with Pelosi Wolf Effron & Spates law firm, which represents AR magazine in the case, was quoted by AR as saying: “The fact they filed this notice voluntary discontinuance means they knew their motions was meritless and would not success. It’s clear that they totally ignored applicable precedent and privilege afforded under the New York shield law to reporters in New York.”

AR’s Editor-in-Chief Michelle Celarier also criticized Elliott’s court case describing it as a “blatant attempt to bully us,” which backfired. She said the incident should serve as a lesson to those who seek disclosure of confidential information from the media.

Celarier said in her affidavit: “Because hedge funds are private investment vehicles, little information about them is available to the public. New financial regulation is passed in Congress this year will change that very little. At the same time, this industry controls close to $2tln in assets globally. Historically hedge funds were for the super wealthy, but now college endowments and corporate and public pensions are becoming their dominant investors. These investors have long clamored for more transparency, a call that became louder after the financial crisis of 2008… Our economy, our educational institutions and our retirements are best served by a financial media that is independent of financial pressure or coercion.”

Celarier’s affidavit was supposed to be submitted on Sept. 02.

The legal battle between Elliott and AR magazine started when the hedge fund filed a petition before the New York Supreme Court asking the trade publication to name the source of the article so they could initiate an internal investigation and determine who leaked its investor report.

Elliott maintained that disclosure of its quarterly position would hurt its competitive edge against rival hedge funds.

According to the New York Observer, AR’s article was picked up by several publications including the New York Post. And the subsequent petition by Elliott caused a major outcry among the media industry claiming the court case violated freedom of speech.

Elliott case highlights hedge fund transparency and New York shield law
Among the thorny issues that cropped up in the Elliott vs AR magazine case are whether trading positions found in investor letters are proprietary information, as some fund managers claim, and the issue of transparency in the hedge fund industry, as demanded by investors and lately regulators.

In an exclusive interview with Opalesque on Monday, Nick Roger, partner at global law firm Ogier explained that there are three ways in which fund managers can claim confidentiality of their information. One is to include a statement on the document stating that no information or data can be disclosed or reproduced. Another is to require investors to sign an undertaking to pledge to keep any information regarding the fund confidential. And finally, fund managers can copyright investor communications.

For his part, Paul Chain, partner at the global firm AIS Fund Administration, said the definition of transparency is really quite a big issue among fund administrators and investors. “Just as there are some things that a manager should be allowed to keep secret because they are related to the ways that manager keeps their edge in the market, there are some things that should not be kept secret.” (See yesterday’s Opalesque Exclusive: here).

Sept. 9 hearing cancelled
With the withdrawal of Elliott’s petition, the scheduled Sept. 9 hearing of the case has already been cancelled by the court, reported the Wall Street Journal.
- Precy Dumlao

What do you think?

   Use "anonymous" as my name    |   Alert me via email on new comments   |   
Banner
Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing
  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Opalesque Exclusive: Rainwater and Blue Sky - an Australian water fund emerges[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: Financial reporters often tout new funds and investments as uncorrelated investments, but few can say they are uncorrelated to everything but weather. Enter Blue Sky Alternative's water fund which invests in the permanent rights to Australia's water. Sev

  2. Regulatory – Expect greater SEC scrutiny of hedge funds that share information or collaborate in advance of their trades, Alternative funds to get SEC test for leverage, liquidity[more]

    Expect greater SEC scrutiny of hedge funds that share information or collaborate in advance of their trades From Thelawyer.com: A recent Wall Street Journal article — ‘Activist investors often leak their plans to a favoured few’ — focused attention on ‘activist’ investors and stock analy

  3. …And Finally – This week's least competent criminal is Austrian[more]

    From ABCnews.go.com: A German sought by authorities for alleged fraud has been arrested in Austria — after dropping into a police station to ask officers whether he was under investigation. Police in Salzburg said the 59-year-old man walked into a police station in the city on Friday night. Sp

  4. Investing – Hedge funds find pitfalls along with profits in real estate ventures, Marcato Capital Management makes new bet on Dillard’s[more]

    Hedge funds find pitfalls along with profits in real estate ventures From Law360.com: Hedge funds have joined the rush to real estate deals and development in recent months to close the financing gap left by tightening bank standards, but attorneys say many aren't prepared for the disclo

  5. Agecroft Partners estimates 90% of hedge funds using social media[more]

    The use of social media has increased significantly within the hedge fund industry over the past couple of years. Social media is broadly used by investors as part of their due diligence process on hedge funds, by service providers in their sales efforts to hedge funds, and by hedge funds to enhance