Thu, Mar 28, 2024
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Futures Intelligence

Index Tracker: Gold, silver and commodity investments.

Friday, October 22, 2010

All that Glitters: Gold and Silver

Commodity indexes did better in the third quarter than the first half of the year, as Barclays Capital analyst Kevin Norrish pointed out in a report. Overall, two key benchmarks, the S&P Goldman Sachs Commodity Index and the Dow Jones UBS index, have been less volatile in 2010 than in the previous two years, a period that included steep drawdowns during the 2008-2009 crisis and the subsequent partial recovery.

Commodities started this year with losses but turned positive in July (table below). One of the intriguing patterns of the past five months is the leading role of precious metals in the commodity rally. Agriculture was also a substantial profit generator, but gold and silver led the commodity pack in returns through September. And in October, gold and silver rose to new highs.

In long-only investments, an uncertain macroeconomic climate kept interest focused on agriculture and precious metals, according to the Barclays Capital report. In August, withdrawals outpaced investments in commodities at large. "Most of the decline was due to a reduction in institutional and retail investor exposure reflected in a $5 billion reduction in broad commodity exposure via index swaps," says Barclays.

In dramatic contrast, demand for gold investments recovered quickly and money flowed to gold exchange-traded funds. Gold investing has been a major part of commodity investments this year. Barclays found that gold accounted for about one-third of the total $29 billion new commodity investments year-to-date as of September.

"The enthusiasm for physical exposure to gold shows investors are still very uneasy about the future," Mr. Norrish comments.

Futures Markets
Hedge funds and commodity trading advisors tracked the rally, keeping large net long positions in precious metals since March. They bought silver and palladium as well as gold. Net long positions in palladium and silver futures were near all-time highs. Net positions in gold futures were the largest since early 2010. Trend followers are riding on the up trends.

While both silver and gold continue to surge, there is an interesting change in the relationship between the two metals. The price ratio of gold to silver has been falling and is now at its lowest since before the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, according to GoldCore-one ounce of gold buys around 56.5 ounces of silver. But that is still high compared to 1980, when the Hunt Brothers cornered the silver market

Silver has several advantages. While the metal is a possible substitute for gold as a hedge against currency depreciation, it is still used as an industrial input. Global growth creates industrial demand for silver. What is more, silver is cheap by historic standards. Thus there is room for the relative price of gold to silver to go down further.

Passive vs. Active Gold
The gold rally has led to forecasts of a bubble in the metal. However, the rush to gold is arguably an attempt by investors to protect themselves against the weakening United States dollar.

Strangely, the Federal Reserve could be seen as a the patron saint of gold bugs! The Fed's zero interest rate policy and quantitative easing to stimulate growth has made US assets - and by implication the US dollar - less attractive. A second round of QE appears to be in the works-see Futures Lab in this issue.

As a result billions of dollars have moved into gold exchange-traded funds and other long-only investments. Paulson & Co and Harbinger, prominent hedge funds but not big commodity players, are among big buyers of gold ETFs.

A small portion of the money flowing to gold has gone to actively managed gold funds and commodity trading advisors. CTAs argue that they have an advantage over long-only commodity investments-they can go short to take advantage of declining markets. If there is a significant downward correction in gold, whether because a bubble collapses or people see better opportunities elsewhere, CTAs and other active managers can still make profits, whereas index investments and ETFs are sure to lose.

That said, gold is a tough market to make money in, whether you use a passive index or managed futures, go long or short. While many now regard it as a safe haven against inflation and currency depreciation, historically gold investing was anything but safe. Before the steep rise of the past decade, it was a persistent loser for some 20 years.

Notwithstanding the argument that active management can exploit market declines, there is no shortage of CTAs who've been burnt by gold. One gold expert lost more than 44% last November. The December gain made up for the November drawdown, but the experience shows how perilous this market can be.

The metal does not necessarily move in line with other commodities. That can work in gold investors' favor- in the crisis year of 2008 precious metals eked out a small positive return even as the energy-dominated Goldman Sachs Commodity Index lost 47%. But at other times the non-correlation works against gold. For instance, during the stock market bust of 2000 precious metals went down while the GSCI returned close to 50%.

Gold certainly can have a place in a diversified long/short CTA portfolio but in the immediate future other commodities have more potential. Grains, rather than gold, look promising in the short term. Barclays expects high prices in a number of commodities in the fourth quarter - oil, base metals and some agricultural products - but not in gold.

Net positions in grain futures spiked in the summer as headlines announced Russia's export ban on wheat and remain at near-record highs as bad harvests point to continuing strength. See the August 17, 2010, issue of Opalesque Futures Intelligence for an interview with agriculture specialist Brooks Brown of Cypress Capital.


Source: Barclays Capital



 
This article was published in Opalesque Futures Intelligence.
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Opalesque Futures Intelligence
Today's Exclusives
Today's Other Voices
More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. KKR raises $6.4bn for the largest pan-Asia infrastructure fund[more]

    Laxman Pai, Opalesque Asia: The New York-based global investment firm KKR has raised a record $6.4bn for its second Asia-focused infrastructure fund, underlining investors' continued appetite for private markets. According to a media release from the alternative assets manager, the figure top

  2. Bucking the trend, top hedge fund makes plans for a second SPAC[more]

    From Institutional Investor: SPACs aren't dead. At least not to the folks at Cormorant Asset Management. The life sciences firm, whose hedge fund topped its peers in 2023, is confident it will match the success of its first blank-check company. Last week, the life sciences and biopharma speciali

  3. Benefit Street Partners closes fifth fund on $4.7 billion[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York: Benefit Street Partners has closed its fifth flagship direct lending vehicle, BSP Debt Fund V, with $4.7 billion of investable capital across the strategy. Benefit Street invests primarily in privately originated, floating rate, senior secured loans. The fun

  4. 4 hedge fund themes that are working in 2024[more]

    From The Street: A poor earnings report from Tesla (TSLA) has not hurt the indexes on Thursday. The decline in Tesla stock, which is losing its position in the Magnificent Seven pantheon, is more than offset by strong earnings from IBM (IBM) and ServiceNow (NOW) . In addition, the much higher-t

  5. Opalesque Exclusive: A global macro fund eyes opportunities in bonds[more]

    Bailey McCann, Opalesque New York for New Managers: Munich-based ThirdYear Capital rebounded in 2023, following a tough year for global macro. The firm's flagship ART Global Macro strategy finished the year up 1