Sat, Dec 20, 2014
A A A
Welcome Guest
Free Trial RSS
Get FREE trial access to our award winning publications
Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence

Industry Snapshot: Islamic Dinar Revisited By Mobasher Zein

Thursday, December 16, 2010

The writer is an Islamic finance researcher who completed his MBA (Investment Management) from Concordia University and is a CFA Level 3 candidate. He was recently awarded the Islamic Finance Qualification (IFQ) designation.

A Super Sovereign

Calls for reforming the international monetary system have picked up pace with Zhou Xiaochuan, Governor of the People's Bank of China opining that the IMF's SDR should be widened in scope and allocation and presents the best possible solution in securing global stability and facilitating world economic growth.[i] The criteria he presents in selecting an international reserve currency are:

i. Stable value
ii. Rule-based issuance
iii. Manageable supply[ii]

Clearly, a new Islamic Dinar weighted to equal 4.3 grams of gold and an Islamic Dirham weighted at 3 grams of silver will exceed the established criteria prescribed by the governor in terms of its intrinsic value, convertibility and flexibility. It is entirely independent from the economic conditions and geo-economic interests of any single country and directly addresses the Triffin dilemma by providing liquidity while maintaining value. Similarly, it is a far superior alternative to the Bancor currency proposal of John Maynard Keynes whose world currency unit fixed in terms of 30 commodities seems impractical and unstable.

Intriguingly, the UNCTAD's Trade and Development Report of 2010 also highlight the challenges being faced by the international monetary system and the use of US Federal Reserve notes as the world's reserve currency.[iii] Unfortunately, the solutions presented by the authors fall woefully short of meaningful financial reform where replacing the US dollar with an artificial SDR currency is seen as a remedy to budget deficits and instability. It would be difficult to expect the thoroughly discredited International Monetary Fund, with its standard prescription of shock therapy austerity measures for developing economies, to act as a neutral arbiter in supervising its implementation and working.

Proposals
A drastic restructuring of the existing financial disorder will require the Islamic Development Bank to play a leading role in transforming the current central banking warfare investment model[iv] that governs the planet with the establishment of a new monetary regime that actually enhances economic welfare, help formulate monetary policy of all Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) member states and provide a platform and basis for greater economic integration of Muslim countries. Specifically, the Islamic Development Bank would be tasked to:

1) A new Islamic Central Bank (Baat ul Maal) -a bank of last resort for all OIC member central banks with powers and functions similar to the Bank of International Settlements tasked with engendering greater stability through guidelines and regulations across the entire spectrum of the Islamic financial system. Its principal task will be to coordinate and manage monetary policy of the new Islamic Dinar providing liquidity and limiting supply as international market conditions dictate. It will also be mandated to ensure that member central banks actively replace conventional banking practices with Sharia compliant operations in their respective jurisdictions. The new central bank will need to settle the debate on an Islamic interest rate and provide a principal benchmark rate that will be used to price all future Islamic financial contracts. The underlying drivers of the new Islamic interest rate will need to be carefully selected and endorsed by consensus with fatwa across all five schools of Islamic thought. Certainly, the IDB would need to mobilize member states particularly Saudi Arabia, Malaysia and Turkey to provide impetus and focus for an independent and empowered central bank that will lie of the heart of new Islamic financial system.

2) Regional commodity exchanges -across the Arab/Islamic world regional commodity exchanges will set commodity prices and settle trades in Islamic Dinars. Maintaining constant demand for the new Islamic Dinar will be necessary to gain traction and credence in the forex market. Possible options can include but are not limited to:
 

Commodity

Location

Oil

Dammam, Saudi Arabia

Gas

Doha, Qatar

Precious Metals

Dubai, UAE

Cotton

Istanbul, Turkey

Cocoa

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Rice

Karachi, Pakistan

Jute

Dhaka, Bangladesh


3) Restrict derivative use -ban any form of 'naked' short-selling of the new Islamic Dinar across all international currency markets. The OIC should seek a treaty at the multilateral level if need be to protect the currency from harmful speculative attacks orchestrated by the economic hit-men of Wall Street and the City of London. The new Islamic Central Bank could consider charging a special tax on hot money flows that are outside the purview of normal monetary exchanges to desist speculators.

4) Islamic Monetary Union (IMU) - Develop a phased program for the adoption of the Islamic Dinar by OIC member countries provided certain macro-economic benchmarks are met. An Islamic version of the Maastricht treaty (as described by my colleague Bernardo Vizcaino), is initiated where the formulation of monetary policy at the state level is subordinated to a supranational body that will be responsible for coordinating and integrating Muslim countries under a single economic platform. The roll-out should be gradual and incremental on a country by country basis where admission to the program is contingent on matching specific economic criteria and membership is guaranteed through continued adherence with fiscal and monetary benchmarks of the program. Drawing upon the experiences of the Gulf Cooperation Council the new Islamic Monetary Union should seek to avoid the petty squabbling that marred the GCC monetary union debate through transparency and accountability of its proposed operations. An important outcome of the new monetary regime will be 'dinarization' that should occur as OIC member states seek to conform to the new IMU. The decline of the US dollar will make it necessary for countries to seek alternative means to ensure fiscal and monetary discipline of individual member states. With dinarization central banks of member states will be in no position to print money ad infinitum thereby constraining local money supply, preserving the value of local currencies while resulting in an acceptable loss of seigniorage.

5) An exclusive Free Trading Zone - The formation of an expanded free trade area within the Arab/Islamic world is sorely needed. A free trading zone that harmonizes tariffs and trade with non-Muslim world while removing intra-trade barriers should provide the right ingredients for specialization and sectoral growth in the OIC. The new IMU using the Islamic Dinar as the principal currency of exchange while enabling the free mobility of capital and labor will unleash untapped economic synergies benefiting millions across the Islamic world. This should also provide the Islamic Dinar with the real chance of becoming an alternate reserve currency of the world as countries build up their Dinar holdings.

Conclusion
A strategic reform of the international monetary system has become a moral imperative for the world's economic managers. The question is one of willingness and capacity to replace the existing the disorder in the international financial system with one that is ordered, robust and stable. It is my firm belief that a new Islamic currency will play a critical role in the evolution of such a system although whether this call is heeded remains to be seen. Consensus-building will take time but the forces of globalization have provided an excellent opportunity for Muslim countries to develop their own economic bloc in this rapacious new world order. The urgent need to strategically reorder the Islamic financial landscape in to a system that underscores its moral and ethical value system is long over-due. The Islamic world needs a renaissance and no single dynamic will give it as much momentum as a new Islamic currency that binds the old with the new.

References
[i] The People's Bank of China, online article, September 9, 2010
[ii] Ibid
[iii] The Telegraph, "UN wants new global currency to replace dollar", September 9, 2010
[iv] Catherine Austin Fitts, online article, September 9, 2010


Your feedback and comments are very important to us, please feel free to contact the author via email.



Article Link

<< Go Back to Archive

Today's Exclusives Today's Other Voices More Exclusives
Previous Opalesque Exclusives                                  
More Other Voices
Previous Other Voices                                               
Access Alternative Market Briefing


  • Top Forwarded
  • Top Tracked
  • Top Searched
  1. Investing - Big hedge funds win again on PetSmart, Riverbed, RBS sells real estate loans to hedge fund Cerberus, Talisman energy speculation: Which hedge funds could benefit?[more]

    Big hedge funds win again on PetSmart, Riverbed From CNBC.com: Another week, another set of wins for activist investors. On Sunday, pet supply retailer PetSmart agreed to the largest leveraged buyout of the year at $8.7 billion. Hedge fund firm JANA Partners had been pushing for a sale a

  2. Outlook - Hedge fund manager who remembers 1998 rout says prepare for pain, Bond guru Bill Gross predicts U.S. economic growth to dip to 2%[more]

    Hedge fund manager who remembers 1998 rout says prepare for pain From Bloomberg.com: Stephen Jen landed in Hong Kong in early January 1997 as Morgan Stanley’s newly minted exchange-rate strategist for Asia. He was soon working around the clock when investors began targeting the region’s

  3. Investing - Hedge funds get boost from healthcare in 2014, Paulson & Co takes stake in Salix on heels of inventory issues[more]

    Hedge funds get boost from healthcare in 2014 From Valuewalk.com: The healthcare sector started the year on a turbulent note, as stocks of many major biotechnology companies were battered. However, most of the players in this sector have bounced back. The BarclayHedge Healthcare & Biotec

  4. Comment - High fees and low performance hit hedge funds[more]

    From FT.com: Disenchantment over high fees and lackluster performance may finally be turning the tide against hedge funds, fresh data suggest. Despite generally weak returns since the global financial crisis, hedge funds have enjoyed positive net inflows every year since 2010. This helped assets und

  5. Performance - Lansdowne, Man Group, other hedge funds profit from shorts in oil, Turmoil boosts hedge funds that bet against Russia, oil, CTAs post strongest returns since December 2010[more]

    Lansdowne, Man Group, other hedge funds profit from shorts in oil From Valuewalk.com: The rising short interest in oil companies implies that the worst for oil is yet to come. Data from Markit shows that short exposure in energy sector of S&P 500 is still looming close to the highest mar